The Pennsylvania Progressive
...all rights reserved...



John Morgan
Blog Owner, Editor, Publisher

PA Eagle Eye
Contributing Writer
Walter Brasch
Contributing Writer
Contributing Writer
Great Auk
Site Administrator

Contact: PAprogressive(at)Gmail(dot)com


Advanced Search

Progressive Allies
Common Sense 2
Act Blue
Beaver County Blue
Democracy For America
Pennsylvania For Democracy
The Nation
Progressive Democrats of America
OpEd News
Misled Into War: A Timeline
Lefty Blogs
The Advocate
Democracy For Berks
Kutztown Area Democratic Club
Pennsylvania Diversity Network
Upper Bucks For Democracy
People For the American Way
The Raw Story
Tredyffrin Township Democrats
Public Citizen
The New PA 16th
Progressives For Pennsylvania
Casino Free Philadelphia
Air America Radio
Progressive Majority
Democratic Talk Radio
Dems '08
Equality Forum
Human Rights Campaign
Equality Advocates
Green Party of PA
Americans Against Escalation In Iraq
Northern Chester County Dems
Eastern PA PFLAG

News and Resources
WGPA Radio
The Accountability Project
Politics PA
The Real Sam Rohrer
BBC News
PennLive News Flash
National Public Radio
Federal Election Commission
Open Secrets
Coalition For Voting Integrity
PA Commissions, Elections, Legislation
Project Vote Smart
Iraq On The Record
The Cook Political Report
Neighborhood Networks
Public Radio Capitol News
Money Line
Fair Trade
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
The Philadelphia Inquirer
Harrisburg Patriot News

The Pennsylvania Progressive

Ex Judges Claiming Judicial Immunity

by: John Morgan

Wed Sep 23, 2009 at 10:25:27 AM EDT

The two former Luzerne County Judges being prosecuted for denying juveniles their constitutional rights to due process in return for $2.6 million in cash from a privatized detention system company are fighting a class action lawsuit against them.  Michael Conahan and Mark Ciavarella are arguing they have judicial immunity from such suits.  Nineteen former judges and legal scholars are contesting the argument claiming such a decision would make the concept a mockery.

The idea of judicial immunity is to protect judges from being sued for actions they take from the bench.  I doubt it was designed to protect corrupt judges who are on the take.

From the brief:

"Application of immunity to judges who admitted under oath to engaging in a criminal scheme for years would indeed be monstrous," attorney Sara B. Richman, who filed the brief on behalf of the legal scholars, says in court papers. "To find immunity would denigrate the respect of the public for the judiciary, which is dependent upon judges making decisions based on the law and the facts, rather than personal, corrupt motives."

Abraham Gafni, one of the nineteen wrote this persuasive argument:

"There was a sense of perversion of the legal doctrine of judicial immunity, that it was being applied where it was never intended to be applied," said Gafni, a former court of common pleas judge. "Judicial immunity is not meant to protect judges who are admittedly engaging in criminal activity."

The judges are accused of accepting kickbacks in return for sentencing juvenile offenders to the company's privatized juvenile detention facility.  They denied them right to lawyers during their court proceedings in order to conceal the extent of their judicial misconduct and alleged crimes.  Both judges filed guilty pleas then withdrew them and opted for trials.

Meanwhile Superior Court Judge Jack Panella, head of the ethics commission for the state judges says they received a complaint about Conanhan and Ciavarella and forwarded it to prosecutors, an action which precipitated the investigation.  This is how good judges protect us from the few bad ones.  In this case the system worked.

While Judge Panella was doing this his opponent for Supreme Court was out speaking to Tea Baggers.  Joan Orie Melvin, being widely accused by many of ethical misconduct on the campaign trail, addressed radical fringe protesters in Lehighton.  I have received several reports of people at closed door meetings with Judge Melvin saying she is openly offering to fix upcoming cases in return for key endorsements.  How this is much different from what Conahan and Ciavarella did is vague.  Either way judges are for sale.  The big trouble with corrupt judges is that someone else may come along with a better offer and ruin your fix.

Now storm clouds are circling over another Luzerne County Judge.  This time it is Judge Joeseph Musto whose son got an ARD after being charged with drug possession, resisting arrest and disorderly conduct.  The Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition program is supposed to only be for first time offenders but young Joseph Musto doesn't qualify due to a previous record.  Oops...

While the issue of ethics and integrity is central to this year's appellate court elections Judge Melvin is out talking to tea baggers and promising to fix cases while Jack Panella is running an open, honest campaign after a distinguished career watching over evil doers and bad Judges.

John Morgan :: Ex Judges Claiming Judicial Immunity
Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Active Users
Currently 0 user(s) logged on.


Make a New Account



Forget your username or password?

Pennsylvania Blogs
PA 2010
Drexel Dems
Kill Gerrymandering In PA
2 Political Junkies
A Big Fat Slob
A Smoke Filled Room
Above Average Jane
Beer Leaguer
A Lehigh Valley POV
Carbon County Democrats For Change
PA Labor Movement
PA Dems
Declarations of Pride
Diondega 412
Erie Gay News
Erie Pressible
Froth Slosh B'Gosh
Future Majority
Green Dog Dem
Jesse White
Keystone Politics
Left Of Centre
Lehigh Valley Ramblings
Pennsylvania Independent
Mark Rauterkus & Running Mates
MainLine Peace Action
Making Sense With Don L
Metroblogging Philadelphia
Montco DFA
Harrisburg Politics
Philly Future
Pittsburgh Lesbian Correspondents
Progress Pittsburgh
Suburban Guerrilla
Thomas C Waters
The Liberal Doomsayer
Young Philly Politics
The Lehigh Valley Political Blog
All Spin Zone
PA WaterCooler
Truth, Justice & Peace
Wilkes-Barre Online

State Blogs
The Albany Project
Article XI
Bleeding Heartland
Blogging For Michigan
Blue Commonwealth
Blue Hampshire
Burnt Orange Report
Buckeye State Blog
Prairie State Blue
Square State
My Left Nutmeg
Florida Politics
Forward Kansas
Free State Politics
Hillbilly Report
Indigo Journal
Left In Alabama
Left In The West
Loaded Orygun
Turn Maine Blue
Blue Mass Group
Michigan Liberal
Nebraska Netroots
Minnesota Progressive Project
New Dominion Project
New Nebraska
Blue Jersey
Blue Oklahoma
Show me Progress
Green Mountain Daily
West Virginia Blue
Blog Roll
Bad Attitudes
Border Jumpers
Booman Tribune
Bootstrapping Andrew Sullivan
Crooks and Liars
Culture Kitchen
Daily Kos
Deer Jane
Delaware Liberal
Down With Tyranny
Group News Blog
Hullabaloo (Digby)
Kid Oakland
Media Matters
Politics of Mesothelioma
Mid Atlantic Labor Blog
My Left Wing
Oliver Willis
Nourishing the Planet
Organized For Once
Open Records
Pam's House Blend
Politico's Ben Smith
Planned Parenthood Action Fund
Queah's Blog
Rubber Hose
Senate Guru
Swing State Project
Talking Points Memo
Talk Left
Terrorism News
The Brad Blog
The Gist
The Bilerico Project
The Huffington Post
The Jaundiced Eye
The Quaker Agitator
Think Progress
Iraq Today
Informed Consent

Powered by: SoapBlox